I've stayed very quiet on the new show on here, largely due to the fact that opinions here aren't generally well received if they are anything less than 100% positive, but I'll be honest, I'm very happy the show has been picked up for a full season!
So far for me, the show has very much been bad, good, bad, good, bad... I feel that, probably due to the fact they are trying something different, the results are very uneven and there is something not quite gelling with me at present.
I am one of quite an exclusive club that feels the recent Muppet output peaked with Muppets Most Wanted. For me, particular in the extended edition, the Muppets were the closest they have ever been recently to the Muppets I(!!) loved. After the first episode in the new series, I actually (and very prematurely) said to a friend that I wished they finally hung up the characters for good and let them live on in "nostalgialand" - I am quite glad they didn't.
The new show presents many of the beloved characters in a way completely unfamiliar to me that is very hit and miss. Fozzie has been losing me for years and this series isn't changing that. He used to be one of my favourite characters but these days I really don't care for him at all. Piggy too has begun to grate on me more than amuse. The nasty diva schtick has become tired and for the most part she has become a very one dimensional caricature of someone who used to be so incredible.
Kermit too is leaving me a bit cold. Strangely, this is more acceptable to me because it is the negative aspects of his character that I don't like, but it is fleshing out his character - if that makes any sense?? To me, there's no flaws to Kermit. He's the character that gets pushed to his limits but at the end of the day is the moral barometer for the group. To see him be mean(?), name call etc is taking some getting used to but it is a new aspect to his character.
In general, I think this show has a great deal of hope and potential and I think now that it has the opportunity develop over a full season, it has chance to possibly be one of the best Muppet outputs to date...I hope. I have laughed quite hard on one or two occasions. Pepè, who I feel has carried the Muppets a lot over recent years, is delivering some awesome moments after being largely absent in the last two movies and I feel the writers really need to use him more.
Scooter is now back to his peak and I am loving him as much as I ever have. That said, I hated(!!) the eye-thing and hope that they never(!!!) do that again. It's one of the brilliantly unexplainable quirks of the Muppets that certain characters have no eyes behind glasses and I feel that really ruined that.
It's great having Rizzo back and Uncle Deadly has surprisingly become the standout character of the series.
Fingers crossed the creators iron out some of the creases and win a loyal viewership over the remaining shows and we get a very strong season 2. I hope that the extension lets the writers see what is working and what isn't and possibly do the impossible and please everyone of us...if that is possible.
To end on a positive, some of the puppetry has been mind blowing and I look forward to more of that - this weeks Piggy number in particular was remarkable.
*before you hate, please understand this is just my opinion based on what the Muppets mean to me.