Wow, just wow. I know this thread is oldish but it's really interesting, and everyone's thoughts are really insightful. That said, the Miss America thing is awful, but I've never really been a fan of beauty standards myself, let alone pageants focusing on such things. I'm a very body-positive person, so I've never focused too much on my appearance in the way of weight as such, but I try to be healthy to some extent. In honesty, I embrace the fact that everyone comes in shapes and sizes. <3 The 'real women have curves' thing does annoy me a little, though. While I understand what they mean by saying that, and I like the body-positive message, you can still be skinny (/even/ unhealthily skinny, which I don't like and is pretty off-putting in my books) and be a 'real woman', you know? I hate the message it gives out to women, though. 'Plus-size models' are, like, my weight and less from what I've seen, though there's exceptions.
Going to an all-girls' school, I hear people talking about weight... quite a bit. Luckily, there's not a massive focus on the whole, 'oh, I'm sooo fat' thing. I've experienced a few things in the past with some of my friends (in particular, ones that weighed a fair bit more than me) jumping to the conclusion that I had an eating disorder (their words, not mine), basically because I ate less than them and exercised more, and they were really iffy about this. Although I'm not one to go on about my weight, I am considered underweight according to the BMI (which is often a stupid measure anyway), and I weigh a lot less than I look (probably because I don't have much muscle- lol!), and these friends of mine have often called me scrawny (and trust me, if you've seen me, I'm /really/ not xD), and found it 'icky' because you can very, /very/ vaguely see my ribs, and when I would tell them that what they were saying wasn't accurate at all, they would act as though I thought I was overweight, dissecting everything I'd say under a microscope, there really is no middle ground. Luckily, my parents never gave me crap about my weight but a few people did when I was younger, and that was a little annoying because you're more impressionable and such, but I couldn't care less really at present (for example, I never look at the sizes on clothes, I don't know what my size is in anything). xD
I'm sorry about your experiences with your dad, Julia. D: <3