I tend to like BOTH, but I think the second was far stronger for dumping the Brady Bunch-style self parody stuff. It's stuff that's funny at first, but becomes tedious. Only thing I really disliked about the second was that random pointless bit with that fat guy who just won American Idol. But hey, Scott MacNeil was in it. So rarely do you see Canadian voice actors in live action American movies... though, trust me on this... during one of the army war room scenes in Watchmen, you can see Gary Chalk, and he even has a couple lines.OK I'm going to say I actually enjoyed the first Scooby Doo movie, lol. It was clunky at times but the in jokes were very funny and I thought they did a good job with why the characters resenting each other and all.
But anyway... Are they going to make this entirely CGI, or partially, or what?