dwmckim
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Apr 13, 2002
- Messages
- 2,874
- Reaction score
- 848
Well, if those are your only two choices, no wonder you're confused!I'm kind of confused, it's been said on here that the act of homo sexuality is a sin. I always thought that was a lifestyle, am I wrong?
I'll give you my thoughts in a moment but first let me ask you a question:
Is your heterosexuality a lifestyle or a sin?
I'm not being smart or funny (though i won't protest if anyone wants to think of me as either!) - but really, when people want to talk about what being gay "is" and "isn't", it really helps clarify things if they first think about what the answers to the same questions asked back at them about their being straight are and how you would personally answer.
What is a "gay lifestyle"? Wish i knew. It sounds like something where everyone attends fabulous soirees looking immaculately gorgeous with perfect hair and designer-label-only clothes and you get a free toaster after kissing your first boy! Wearing polyester or white after Labor Day means immediate surrender of your Gay Card. There's a secret handshake and we all have a special choreographed dance we all do perfectly whenever a Donna Sommer song is played and we pray each night at the alter of Barbara (but we're only allowed to call her "Babs") Streisand. Each get together must include club sandwiches on wheat bread and we earn bonus points any time you say "oh SNAP", "FAB-u-lous" or the Special Word of the Day (today's word is "divine"). We hold intellectual panel discussions over red wine debating such topics as "are there really such a thing as straight Muppet Freaks?"
Sounds nifty. Where do i sign up?
I don't have a "lifestyle" much less a "gay lifestyle". We all come from different walks of life and have different experiences, likes/dislikes, views, etc. If one was to use me as an example, a "gay lifestyle" would be defined as being alone, seldom dating, facing both overt and subtle discrimination for being above my ideal weight from within the gay community and totally browbeat from the straight community having faced just about every possible form of anti-gay bigotry there is (with the thankful exception of physical violence): job loss, home loss, family loss, theft, vandalism of home and car, harassment, etc - and i'm not even dating or having/enjoying any of the "benefits"! (Honestly, if a large portion of my life is going to include actively being persecuted for being gay, shouldn't i at least have a hot boyfriend so all that suffering isn't in vain?) My "gay lifestyle" means being dirt poor and constantly terrified of how i'm going to pay this month's bills while driving around in a car that's falling apart in a dozen different ways and is just a matter of time before i can't use it anymore and having to squint at everything because i can't afford an updated eye exam to get new contact lenses to replace the eight month old ones i'm wearing now.
But enough about the "gay lifestyle" - what's the "straight lifestyle"? Donna Reed? Jersey Shore? Desperate Housewives? The Munsters? Married...with Children? MTV Spring Break? Which of those is the correct representation of it?
So "lifestyle" gets the Big Obnoxious Game Show Buzzer. It's a "nothing" word really used only by opponents to depict us as some mythic iconic image of debauchery and hedonism.
Is it a sin? I dunno - is your heterosexuality?
To me, what makes a person "gay" or "straight" is what they're naturally biologically attracted to. One can either totally accept it or totally deny it or more likely some element in between - but that's what it comes down to (and i'm not even getting into the more nuanced elements of the middle choices on the Kinsey Scale!) Can someone be gay and a virgin? Raises hand. I hold onto the same value systems in regards to relationships i had growing up and the gender involved doesn't change things - i prefer to wait til i have a committed life partner. This is why words like "homosexual" (and "heterosexual") aren't the best choices - they're clinical scientific terms which when taken literally mean "one who has sex with the (same/opposite) gender". Well, by that definition i'm neither het or homo but i sure as heck am no less gay.
Just as straight people do, there are infinite ways a gay person lives their lives and have relationships and treat others. One can treat their relationships as one big drunk college party orgy (straight or gay) or one can treat their partners with love, respect, caring, with the friendship first above all else - or any manner in between. I do not choose to be gay and i'm sure you'd say you don't choose to be straight. You just are. What we DO choose is how we engage in our relationships and treat others. And yes, there's any number of what can be viewed as "wrong choices" (again both gay and straight alike) - and one person's right may be another's wrong and vice versa.
To go back to your original question of "what is it?" Well, any dictionary worth its salt will give multiple definitions for just about any word within it and various contexts a word may be used. Which is part of the reason so many people have a hard time seeing eye to eye about gays - they're using the same words but speaking different languages.
I don't see my gayness as a choice. I don't see it as a sin. All i know is that at the end of the day i dream of being held tightly and lovingly in Ben Browder or Scott Evans' arms rather than Courtney Cox's or Vanna White's or whoever them straight folk are tweetin' about these days.
(oh, and by the way...)
I so want this on a t-shirt! S'pose i can get one at the Local Gay Lifestyle Boutique at the Special Gay Lifestyle Membership Discount of 10% if i say the Fabulous Gay Lifestyle Word of the Day and tell them "Judy sent me"?If my gaining equal civil rights actually does bring about a plague of frogs, I promise to buy them all tiny banjos!