I've been back now for nearly a year, and here's my take on what the MC community has been like during this time...
It would seem to me that the community in on what some would call an emotional roller coaster, because it seems like there's periods where the entire community has its ups and high points, then there's periods where it's like the entire community is bitter and resentful.
Since my initial joining of this community in August of 2003, I didn't really start becoming an active part until about 2005 or so, but from my perspective, MC has virtually been THE place to be, not only as a Muppet fan, but for a cool little hangout from at least 2003 to about 2008... I think a lot of people would agree that 2008 is when things around here really started to go downhill, and it seems like since then, at times, the community has tried to pick itself up (this thread is a big example of that very thing), but then no sooner does that happen, and it's like the forum goes to pot again; I can't really give a solid opinion on what the community has been like from November 2008 to the summer of 2009, but since then, as I've said, there's been up and down periods. The biggest down period I can think of during this time was last September's little snafu over the sudden thread closure spree that annoyed a lot of people so much that people were PUBLICALLY pleading for a stop to the thread closures. Naturally, the holidays (October through February), things seemed a little more cheery around here, and for a while, it looked almost as if MC was getting back to normal (or as normal as normal can be around here), but it seems like since March or so, the community has really gone downhill again; the sad thing is, I've noticed a lot more people who used to be regulars and predominately active have been disappearing lately, and whenever I talk with them, they too cite the state of affairs with the community, and the "high school drama"-esque atmosphere as to what's driving them away from here. I partially agree with that, as I've said for years, cliques have always been a bit of a problem here at MC, but from my standpoint, I don't think cliques are really the main problem with the community at the moment, but rather, general hostility... almost as if the community itself has been split into two sides, like the Hatfields and the McCoys (or the Hatfulls and the Floyds if you live in Missouri).
I really don't know what ALL it's going to take to return MC back to "normal", I could see a few improvements that could be done, but I don't think any number of improvements would help restore order PERMANENTLY around here... in my opinion, I think after all is said and done, the MC community will now, and forever more be a roller coaster of ups and downs, but right now, it seems like it's 2008 all over again, and quite frankly, I think I too need a break from all the madness around here.