Wes, thanks for the input. I actually talked to Heather Henson regarding puppets & fleece, and she said they started making them out of fleece really only because coats were made of that as a trend back in the day. Had that not been the trend, they might have been made of something else, setting a completely different standard.
Still, that doesn't negate the fact that they continue to use it & even then made only one puppet out of a coat. We were dicussing trends & materials when it got brought up.
Lets be fair and qualify here:
Antron Fleece is an excellent material for making puppets when you are going for the same sort of finish as that seen on many of the Muppets. And, because the Muppets are probably the world's most recognizable puppets in both character and style, they have the luxury of being the ones who set the standard.
That being the case, many people will desire to acheive the same sort of finish. So Antron Fleece is the material to use. Being that this is MUPPET CENTRAL, you will most likely find an overriding bias towards this standard here.
HOWEVER, if one should desire to create a look that is NOT guided by the design stylings of the Muppets (and please, Lord, let there be puppeteers who DON'T want their stuff to look like the Muppets!), it is well worth the while to investigate as many other building materials as you can.
Personally, I never refer to anything as "substandard" unless it is an example of poor quality within it's own material group. For example, real wool felt is much lovlier to work with than polyester felt. So I will refer to poly felts as substandard. But even they have their uses... and they are often less than half the price of higher quality wool felts.
But one thing that professional puppet builders will always tell you is to explore other materials... don't just accept the obvious. If that was the way to do it, the Muppets would still be made out of old wool peacoats!
-Gordon