Labyrinth
I wholeheartedly agree with jeffboy on many of the issues concerning this dvd release. Very, very lackluster.
Last night I had the opportunity to also pop in the 2nd disc of Labyrinth, and I also found a mixed bag. I don't want to sound overly critical or pesimistic. I am certainly not trying to be. I am merely comparing this release with the many that have been released thus far, and you can easily see the shortcomings. And when you begin to announce spectacular anniversary editions, you naturally expect more, and both releases fall short of that goal. Which is frankly, very very surprising.
Labyrinth, in some ways, was a little better (I stress little), which I was shocked at. I noticed more attention to detail, more information and time given to Brian Henson, and more thoughtful and insightful reflections. Granted, the new recordings still suffered from a blandness and a quick cut and run appeal, it makes you wonder at times, just what they were doing while preparing for this?
Henson needs better designers that is for sure. The DVD's lack any kind of animation or interactive menus of any kind, and that just screams low budget and a half hearted effort. I don't think I'm being picky, I've seen worse movies, treated better, which is mind numbing (and DVD's have been out long enough for them to spend the extra time to make it engaging, its almost standard now). As far as new footage, I guess its in there, here and there, if you blink, you just might miss it. I was expecting a particular menu or button to lead you to some extra footage, but, well, its not there.
I have yet to watch the movie, but since owning the Superbit of both of these films, I'm sure they are very close in their transfers.
Sorry fellas. I've just got to be honest. I am disappointed. It leaves you scratching your head saying out loud "this is the anniversary edition. . .really?" I"m sure Brian Frouds commentary is fantastic, he seems to be an eloquent speaker, and that will be worth it alone probably. But the overall feel is just cheap, it feels like a quadruple dip and piece-mealed together.
and as stated before, Trevor Jones was just left out again. Perhaps he declined an interview, ok, but no one even mentions the music outside of David Bowie. Trevor Jones has done two fantastic scores for the Henson company, and no one acknowledges it. Odd. Simply odd.
Here is hoping that the 30th Anniversary Edition see's a DVD set that is given more time, energy, focus, interaction, reflection and restored footage that is more comprehensive and less bewildering.