Thanks again to Randall and Kyle for the immense amount of MP3s... here's my updated list.
A Celebration of Me, Grover:
Grover Work Song
Proud of Me
Bear in the Big Blue House:
Welcome to the Blue House
Dreamytime Songs:
Sleepytime on Sesame Street
The Frogs in the Glen
Emmet Otter's Jug-Band Christmas:
All except The Bathing Suit that Grandma Otter Wore and Riverbottom Nightmare Band
Fiesta Songs!:
All
Fraggle Rock:
Just a Dream Away
Gonna Party (Saturday Night)
The Me I Wanna Be
Just A Little Wimp
Gorgs In Glory
Dum Dee Dum (I Wish I Had a Genie)
Once Upon a Time (I Knew My Name)
Whoops! Feelin' Better
Rev
Sleep By the Light of the Moon
Travellin' Free
Goodtime Goombah Soup
The Gorg's Lament (O Woe)
Rollin' Rollin' On
Shine On Me
Dream a Dream (And See)
Keep On Smilin'
Ball of Fire
Bring Back the Wonder
Dum of a Son of a Gun
Eye to Eye
Face Facts, Pack Snacks, Make Tracks
Follow the Road
Magic Be With You (Final Fraggle Rock Closing Credits)
Around the Universe
Get Blue (Goin' Down the Road)
Goodbye, Goodbye
The Gypsy Song (I Sniff the Rose)
Home (Philo and Gunge)
I Knew I Was Good
Sing That Law Again
Hot! Hot! Hot! Dance Songs:
I've Got a New Way to Walk
Me Lost Me Cookie at the Disco
It's a Very Merry Muppet Christmas Movie:
The Moulin Scrooge
Jim Henson's Memorial Service:
All Songs (and the Muppet Music Medley Intro)
Jim Henson: A Sesame Street Celebration:
Share
If I Were
Tadpole
I Wonder 'Bout the World Above Up There
Miss Piggy's Hollywood:
That's Entertainment
Muppet Classic Theater:
Nothing's Too Good For You
Muppet Treasure Island:
All
Muppets Tonight!:
Opening Theme
Once In a Lifetime
I'm Seymour, I'm Pepe
Dancin' In the Dark
Pretty Bunsen
Grape Balls of Fire
Dancin' With Myself
Get Up, Get Down (Coolio and the Muppets)
Numbers!:
Four
Platinum Too:
Just Happy To Be Me
Believe in Yourself
Rocky Mountain Holiday:
All
Sesame Disco!:
Disco Frog
The Happiest Street In the World
Sesame Street:
Somebody Come and Play (Ernie)
What's the Name of That Song? (Ernie and Bert)
Everybody's Song (Miles, Gabi, Elmo, Zoe, Telly, Rosita, and Baby Bear version)
Everyone Needs a Friend (Big Bird, Snuffy, and Abby)
I Am Your Friend (Bob and Telly)
I, Grover
Doin' the Snuffleupagus
It Feels Good When You Sing a Song (Hoots and John Legend)
Sing After Me (Ernie and Elmo)
Pigeons, Cookies, and Trash
My Triangle
Bein' Green (Oscar version)
Imagination (Ernie and Bert)
Air (Bip Bipbopada version)
Alphabet Rap (Miles and the Monsters)
Baa Baa Bamba
Eight Balls of Fur
Telephone Rock
It Takes a Street (Hoots)
Alligator King
Do Wop Hop
Counting Vacation
Let's Go Driving
Fat Cat Scat
Get Along Song
See You Tomorrow (Bob)
In My Book
In the Quiet of the Evening
Just One Person (David)
What a Morning (Luis and Maria's Wedding Day)
Things That I Remember
We All Sing With the Same Voice
The Word is "No"
Sesame Street LIVE!:
All
Shrek 2 (I think Kyle has this...):
All
Silly Songs:
There's a Hole in the Bottom of the Sea
The Honker-Duckie-Dinger Jamboree
I'm Proud to Be a Cow
Splish Splash: Bathtime Fun:
Do De Rubber Duck
The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland:
All
The Best of Elmo:
All
The Fantastic Miss Piggy Show:
You Light Up My Life
Lulu of a Luau
Miss Piggy's Musical Medley
The Gang's All Here:
If I Knew You Were Comin' I'd've Baked a Cake
We Coulda
My Polliwog Ways
The Great Muppet Caper:
All
The Muppet Movie:
All
The Muppet Show:
The Muppet Show Theme (Extended)
Another Opening, Another Show
Aet Rof Owt
Java
You've Got a Friend
The Sheik of Araby
While My Guitar Gently Weeps
When I Need You (Leo Sayer and Miss Piggy)
Some Enchanted Evening (Ernie and Bert)
Do-Re-Mi
Cheesecake
Another Somebody Done Somebody Wrong Song
Borneo
Sam's Song
Six String Orchestra
Ugly
I Never Harmed an Onion
Any Old Iron
That Old Black Magic
Jim Henson's Dead (Stephen Lynch song not actually from TMS)
Rockin' Robin
I'm Five
Cuanto le Gusta
Searchin'
How Could You Believe Me?
With a Little Help from my Friends
Pure Imagination
Just One Person
Pachalafaka
Crocodile Rock
Scooter's Guest Star Song
Macho Man
Do Wah Diddy Diddy
Tomorrow
Fifty Ways to Leave Your Lover
Act Naturally
Ain't Misbehavin'
Ain't Nobody's Business But My Own
Duet Medley (Ethel Merman)
No Business Like Show Business
Baby, It's Cold Outside
Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
Carbon Paper (Annie Sue)
The Cat Came Back
Coconut
Consider Yourself
Danny Boy
The Devil Went Down to Georgia
Don't Dilly Dally On the Way
Don't Go Breakin' My Heart
Friendship (Kermit and Robin)
Frog Kissin'
Magic Garden (Kermit)
Camilla (Gonzo's Song)
My Way (Gonzo)
Hound Dog (Geri and the Atrics)
I'm a Woman (Miss Piggy and Raquel Welch)
I'm in Love With a Big Blue Frog
I'm My Own Grampaw
It's Not Where You Start
Love Will Keep Us Together (Leslie Uggams and Big Bird)
Lullaby of Broadway
Mad About the Frog
Memory Lane (Gonzo)
Mr. Bassman
New York State of Mind
Nobody (Gonzo and Rowlf)
An Old Fashioned Love Song (Paul Williams)
Sad Song (Paul Williams)
Pig Calypso
The Pig Got Up and Slowly Walked Away
They Can't Take That Away From Me (Sweetums and Sandy Duncan)
Tomorrow
Ukelele Lady
Upidee
Varsity Drag
Yes, We Have No Bananas
Waiting at the Church
Won't Somebody Dance With Me
Wotcher Knocked 'Em In the Old Kent Road
The Muppet Show Live!:
All
The Muppets at Walt Disney World:
All
The Muppets Go Hollywood:
All
The Muppets Go to the Movies:
All Songs