This is something that i've been thinking about for a while. What do you think about the older episodes compared to the newer ones? While I think the show is still good at times, I think the show really was more realistic in it's earlier episodes. The show was really a slice of life sort of show, kind of like a more innocent version of Hey Arnold! or a less cartoon-ish version of Ed, Edd n' Eddy. They really had some great episodes that really remind you of being a younger kid and hanging out with your friends. Clarence was really the sweet, fun kid you wish you knew when you were nine. The episode "A Pretty Great Day with a Girl" is a perfect example of that. It's just about two kids playing the whole day away. Clarence connects with a new friend, Amy, who says her parents are getting divorced and she may be moving. And after that episode, we don't see her again. The episode is my favorite because it just shows the simple fun and wonder but also the uncertainty of being a child.
Fast forward to the later episodes of season 1, the ones after Skyler Page left, the show is really weird and over the top. It's gotten way more cartoony to the point that the show has lost much of it's charm and uniqueness. The height of this problem is perfectly highlighted in the episode "Rough Riders Elementary", you know the one where some chicken restaurant takes over their school, and something about a cult, and people turn into chickens, and blah blah blah. And yes, I know that entire plot was just Clarence's made up story, but the fact that I didn't figure that out until closer to the end shows that there's a problem with the overall tone of the show. But even as part of Clarence's imagination, it doesn't even fit very well with the rest of the show, and it doesn't fit well with what was already established with Clarence's personality.
Basically, the writers seem to think that the more outlandish the show is the more entertaining it is, but that's not the case. The earlier episodes made the show an almost instant hit. People loved the characters and the simple, somewhat relatable stories. Now, you'll probably notice a much more mixed reception from viewers.
I dunno if this has anything to do with Skyler Page, but, I think the show did go downhill a little bit after he left. Maybe he actually had more to do with the show than Spencer Rothbell is letting one, or maybe it's just a coincidence. But the dip in enjoyment is certainly noticeable.