minor muppetz
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2005
- Messages
- 16,071
- Reaction score
- 2,655
Lately, I've realized that in the short Duck Dodgers and the 24 1/2th Century, Marvin the Martian is really just a designated villain, as opposed to being a true villain as usual. In most shorts, he's clearly a villain, planning to blow up the Earth or kidnap an earthling for study, but here, he's just claiming a planet in the name of his home planet, the very thing Duck Dodgers is doing. We know that Dodgers claims the planet in the name of the Earth because it has the last remaining source of the shaving cream atom, but we really don't know why Marvin needed to claim it for Mars. Maybe he had evil motivations, maybe it was for the same reason as Dodgers, or maybe it's for a similar reason. Yeah, he did show up right after Duck Dodgers claimed the planet and claimed it himself without knowing it was already claimed, and maybe he is fighting a little dirty, even getting the upper hand in his battles against Duck Dodgers. For all we know, both could just be fighting for their planets (like how people fight for their countries).
I've been meaning to list this under Designated Villain on TV Tropes, either that or Gray and Grey Morality. And I just recently saw on TV Tropes that the cartoon is an allegory for armed races. This is the first I've read that (could it have been mentioned in the audio commentary and I just didn't notice?).
I know that the sequel, Duck Dodgers and the Return of the 24 1/2th Century, is disliked by fans, but I don't think it's that bad. I like the animation, especially the sparkling effects on the ship (was that done by computer?). I like the music (which sounds like music for a typical '70s adventure cartoon). But it also goes nowhere. This time, Marvin is truly a villain, as he plans to destroy the Earth, and yet Daffy doesn't come to that realization after he's told (unlike in Hare-Way to the Stars when Marvin tells Bugs this, Bugs similarly doesn't come to the realization at first but does within a few seconds). Marvin decides to introduce Gossammer to Duck Dodgers without really knowing that he's supposed to be stopping him. Porky saves the day by giving Gossammer a hair cut (and Marvin doesn't seem to be concerned), then Duck Dodgers tries to zap Porky just for making a bunch of puns (and there's a bit of missed opportunities - we don't get puns for "cut it out!" and I think Dodgers says something else that could have had a pun) without them defeating Marvin.
I know that the cartoon is longer when it's shown as part of the Daffy Duck's Thanks-for-Giving Special while portions are cut when it's a stand-alone short, so maybe the longer version makes more sense. I have seen that special, the first time I saw this short, but it's been a long time since I last saw the special and at the time I didn't know that the short version was always edited. I read online that the longer version indeed had Porky defeating Marvin, by trapping him in a straight jacket but then Marvin still manages to send a missile for the Earth. I think I first saw the short on its own a few years after I first saw the special, and I felt like there was something different about Daffy's talk with Porky after he defeated Gossammer from how I remembered it in the special.
I've been meaning to list this under Designated Villain on TV Tropes, either that or Gray and Grey Morality. And I just recently saw on TV Tropes that the cartoon is an allegory for armed races. This is the first I've read that (could it have been mentioned in the audio commentary and I just didn't notice?).
I know that the sequel, Duck Dodgers and the Return of the 24 1/2th Century, is disliked by fans, but I don't think it's that bad. I like the animation, especially the sparkling effects on the ship (was that done by computer?). I like the music (which sounds like music for a typical '70s adventure cartoon). But it also goes nowhere. This time, Marvin is truly a villain, as he plans to destroy the Earth, and yet Daffy doesn't come to that realization after he's told (unlike in Hare-Way to the Stars when Marvin tells Bugs this, Bugs similarly doesn't come to the realization at first but does within a few seconds). Marvin decides to introduce Gossammer to Duck Dodgers without really knowing that he's supposed to be stopping him. Porky saves the day by giving Gossammer a hair cut (and Marvin doesn't seem to be concerned), then Duck Dodgers tries to zap Porky just for making a bunch of puns (and there's a bit of missed opportunities - we don't get puns for "cut it out!" and I think Dodgers says something else that could have had a pun) without them defeating Marvin.
I know that the cartoon is longer when it's shown as part of the Daffy Duck's Thanks-for-Giving Special while portions are cut when it's a stand-alone short, so maybe the longer version makes more sense. I have seen that special, the first time I saw this short, but it's been a long time since I last saw the special and at the time I didn't know that the short version was always edited. I read online that the longer version indeed had Porky defeating Marvin, by trapping him in a straight jacket but then Marvin still manages to send a missile for the Earth. I think I first saw the short on its own a few years after I first saw the special, and I felt like there was something different about Daffy's talk with Porky after he defeated Gossammer from how I remembered it in the special.