They probably would had it not been for the aforementioned share holders running around like chickens with their heads cut off over losing money on the TV side when NO ONE WATCHES TV ANYMORE. But it's not like this is NBC that only has 2 terrible hit shows in The Voice and "Look at us make fun of fat people for an hour and call it inspirational."
You read the criticisms on this very site and it came in three flavors...
- This is absolutely nothing like the old show and Jim Henson didn't make it so it's automatically awful
- This version of Piggy and Kermit doesn't match up exactly with my fan fiction. Fail! I'm insulted that my interpretation of the characters isn't Canon.
- EWWWW! There's so much filth! This is exactly like every single cartoon like Beavis and Butt-Head or South park my mommy didn't let me watch. Why can't it be wholesome like that show about the old women who constantly talk about sex more graphically and frequently from 30 years ago?
But frankly, the problem is this...
The show was rushed into production after an 8 minute pitch, put in a time slot that should have been the safest or ABC, it got treated like crap from viewers because they wanted to try something different instead of just lazily flopping around a Muppet Show Clone, ABC and the Show Runners blabbed to news outlets about how they were going to change the show when changes were happening organically, thus essentially saying "DERP! We failed!" and for the extra bit of dumb#%%ery changed the time slot to not compete with Zooey Deschanel's overrated crapcom, and after months of twisting in the wind and mixed signals from Disney, ABC killed the show to appease stock holders not happy with the Billions from movies Star Wars to Captain America 3.
End of story...
So I just saw the news about this and really, I'm not surprised and I know that some of you aren't either.
However Dr Tooth is absolutely correct - if we're going to put blame on this, WE are the number one why this show didn't go anywhere and all we did was help it get cancelled. I don't believe the second point too much, cause if you've read fan fiction, you know that only a few people actually go with canon for the most part.
But I am TOTALLY in a agreement with the first and third. I know that some of us tried to defend the show, but you go back and look at the comments for every episode and you'll see the majority of complaints are
1. It's not the Muppet Show that I loved as a child
2. I'm too sensitive to watch shows like South Park, American Dad, Family Guy and anything else that a normal person would watch and OMG, Kermit said the h-word and I gots the vapors! Dear heavens! *faints*
I'm being a bit harsh, but that was essentially it. Now look, I'm not going to point fingers when I can't point them at myself - I personally think Michael Bay is single handedly ruining everything I loved about cartoons and for some reason, people continue throwing money at him and before it's over, he's going to be making a Care Bears movie and we're just gonna let him.
With that said, unless something is so very horrible from the get go, I'll give a chance and obviously, if I'm a fan, I'll give it the ole college try before I decide if it's worth it or not. The Muppets, like other shows, struggled the first season. Not every show can knock it out of the park it's first season, but it was getting better.
Look, if you want to relive the Muppet Show, there's this place called YouTube and it's on this thing called the Internet. You can pretty much watch every show, for free, on YouTube. If that doesn't work, there's this place called Amazon where you can exchange money for goods and services. Buy TMS on DVD.
If language and unsightly things aren't your cup of tea, I believe there are cable channels that show nothing but Andy Griffith and Make Room for Daddy. And that's fine - in fact I take offense at you, Dr Tooth, cause the Golden Girls was an awesome show and I will defend it to the death. And the Golden Gs weren't just four women sitting around talking about sex (I think you're confusing this with that horrible Sex in the City show), it was about four women in their 60s+, living life and not holding the image of stereotypical grandmas who we just put in nursing homes to be rid of them.
Back on point - yeah, so we're the number one cause of this. However, number 2 & 3 do go to Disney and ABC. DT is right - NO ONE is watching TV and if they are, we're certainly not watching local channels that much. Why would we when we've got Game of Thrones, Silicon Valley, Veep, Ray Donovan, Homeland, etc on HBO/Starz/Showtime and if that doesn't get you, there's House of Cards, OITNB, Transparent, and other great original shows on Netflix, Amazon, and Hulu.
We just got cable again through my roommate's Playstation and it only comes with local channels on demand (correction, I guess we get Fox now), you know where I get my weekly local stuff?
Hulu.
In fact, the reason we joined the cable portion because of sports - it's baseball and basketball season and to be honest, I was getting a little bored with Netflix (House of Cards is over you know). Now I'm not sure how many of us actually have cable - I'm guessing it's you parents or teens living at home or sports fans - but I haven't had cable for years before now.
I honestly think, if the Muppets were to ever come back, they need to come back on Netflix. They've already proven that they can make excellent series for both adults and kids and they've done original movies from previous ones (like the CTHD sequel and the Pee Wee movie) - now, with that said, these movies are NOT as good as the original (though very few movies are), but I also think too much time passed, which is why they don't work.
The Muppets would work so much better on Netflix - they aren't rushed for time, meaning that we could get the episodes that we want, it gives writers more time to go back to source material and get the characters right and then put them in the context of modern times. TM2011 is the perfect example - characters were in character, K&P were broken but willing to try again (without a publicity stunt), new characters were introduced without taking away from the core and still managed to be a part of the team, etc.
Long rant short (too late) -
- cancellation isn't that much of a surprise (not as much as fan fav Castle being cancelled)
- When pointing fingers, make sure to point them to yourselves (me included)
- No one has/watches local channels/cable
- The Muppets need a comeback on mediums that ARE being watched and that's streaming - bring the movies back to Netflix, make a new original on Netflix which is in the same modern time, but has the heart of the show and movies that we love