Juggling is just not that interesting, especially for a character that has nothing else interesting going on. I don't see why they felt they needed a character that could do that for any other reason than trying to push the boundaries of what Puppets can do. If a character doesn't have any tension, he's hardly a character at all. There's no way this guy could have been used outside of anything but exhibition. There's no sketch potential for him, no character interactions of note. He's all flash and no substance. But it's a pretty impressive flash.
Probably they had Fred Garbo around and were like "Why not take advantage of this?".
I watched bits and pieces of Being Elmo yesterday and was shocked to see there is yet
another street scene featuring this character (he is with Big Bird and Snuffy by Big Bird's nest), so I wonder how many times this character appeared in total. It's just amazing how this stuff gets lost over time, and how CTW really does have everything in their vaults, like the rare clips of Richard's Elmo; that's what really stuck with me from the documentary.
I think I asked this before, but I can't help but wonder... how much Sesame Street footage are we missing? 50%?
Yeah, there was no chance this character was gonna last. Definitely an interesting, rare and forgotten footnote in SS history.