I'd hate to think that after working with SST for over twenty years that Joey would be conceited enough to leave the show because they're doing away with the hosting bits: the only info we have is that he fought for over a year over what he thought was "the heart and soul of the show," you really think he thought that Murray was the heart and soul of SST? I mean, if that were the case, it seems like Caroll would have left years ago because of how Elmo's dethroned Big Bird as the unofficial starring Muppet of the show.
Something tells me that wasn't
the reason he left, but it seems like trying to pull Murray back a bit might have been
a straw among the pile on the camel's back, and we don't really know what the last one was. The "heart and soul" thing seems
pretty sinister sounding, though. Maybe the HBO deal wasn't as "spur of the moment" as we think. But I doubt that less Murray screen time would have had him throw his hands in the air and quit. And even if it had no baring on his decision, I'm sure that the show being a half hour might seem like a good way to change the format back. The half hour reruns
do feature the hosting bits, but the rest of the show seems rushed, and in some cases
edited. And I mean the street stories. I'd say that a half hour relaunch is a prime time to end the "hosted block" format, especially due to the fact that subsegments like Abby's School and Crumby Pictures would be too long to incorporate. The alphabet and number intro songs seem like the perfect sign that Murray's hosting duties were going to dissipate in future episodes. I could see him still doing the "Word on the street" bit in future episodes half hour or not, just not the little guessing games and tune ins. And trust me. I do indeed love these Murray out in the world interacting bits. Much more so than the taped CGI background inserts. But I don't think the show needed them, and I can see them doing away with them.
But if I'm wrong about that, I don't see how they can do those without Joey. Sure, recasts are a thing now, and I defend every one of them when they get the character and chemistry right. And I'm sure if they recast Murray, whoever performs him will do a bang up job. But Joey seems to be doing a
lot more than puppeteering for the show. I'm sure there's some logistics of the hosting bits being lost. I'd say that his departure is a good opportunity to bring the show back to having no real host.