Crazy-Animal,
In my experience of online Muppet fans (I've been on the Muppet fan forums since about 1996/7) quite a number of us are also keen on musicals.
I know I certainly am. Though I must say I tend to be more into watching out for particular performers rather than particular shows. And often I find my enjoyment of a particular show is partly influenced by the performances in it. I'm also kinda lucky in that my fondness for musicals coninsides very nicely with being a muppet-fan, as my favourite musical theatre performer just happens to also be my favourite muppeteer.
But you're question is about favourite shows. So here's five I rather like:
Annie Get Your Gun - I first saw this at The Prince Of Wales Theatre in 1992, when Kim Criswell was playing Annie Oakley. I have about a dozen different albums of the show (needless to say Kim Criswell's EMI classics one is my particular favourite)
Anything Goes - I fell in l;ove with this show thanks to two brilliant studio cast album recordings. The EMI Classics one conduced by John McGlinn, with Kim Criswell and Reno, and the JAY/TER one conducted by John Owen Edwards,with Louise Gold as Reno. For quite a long time I thought I wouldn't see that show on stage, because the recordings were too good. But then Kim Criswell starred in a production at Grange Park Opera, so I decided to go and see that.
Follies - I've seen two productions of this. The first was at Royal Festival Hall in 2002. At it starred: David Durham, Kathryn Evans, Louise Gold, and, Henry Goodman. The highlight was getting to watch Louise Gold's spectacular tap dancing in the song The Story of Lucy And Jessie (a number sometimes dropped from Follies). I loved that whole production so much, especially Henry and Louise's performances, that I felt I wouldn't want to see the show again. However, last year, I decided to go and see a production at The Royal And Derngate Theatre in Northampton, which starred: Julian Forsyth, Jan Hartley, Louise Plowright, and, Alex Gianni. They were jolly good.
Kiss Me Kate - I love the film of this so much I thought I wouldn't want to see it on stage. I had the EMI Classics studio cast album and really liked Kim Criswell and George Devorsky as Bianca and Lucentio on it. But I didn't think much of Joesphine Barstow and Thomas Hampson as Lilli/Kate and Fred/Petruchio on it. Actually I just felt no one could compare to Howard Keel's petruchio, let alone Kathryn Grayson's Kate. However in 1997, I decided to give the Regent's Park Open Air Theatre's production a try. .. Louise Gold was Lilli/Kate and well she more than matched Kathryn Grayson.
Six Pictures Of Lee Miller - I'm not usually all that into new musicals. But I think Jason Carr is a brilliant composer, up there with the good old fashioned ones. And I think this show is just the best example of his work. Living proof that they CAN still make 'em like that, sometimes.