I think the problem is that it seems with exceptions most Christian home video producers are working with such low, low standards, ranging from using puppets bought from
companies that sell ministry material to producers (SG and I have an in-joke about this exact topic) or having the bare minimum of production facilities.
I'm sure the people making these things love God and really want to teach kids about Him. However, there are two problems:
1) Since most major children's programming studios wouldn't touch a religious show with a thirty-five-and-a-half foot pole, the shows simply
can't look as polished as their non-religious competition. (Unless, of coarse, somebody's willing to take a
huge risk - Phil Vischer recieved several donations, including one of $80,000, before
VeggieTales started production.)
2) These shows don't have marketers and researchers working with them. Therefore, they don't understand kids the same way that the majors do, and their shows don't attract an audience the same way.
That and the fact that Veggietales is actually well written and entertaining. I'm no big fan of Christian edutainment, but Veggitales is shockingly enjoyable. Everything else felt like a chore to watch. I remember this very Narmy thing that was some serious animated drama (I forget the name of it) and it was just so over the top it was hard to take serious. Not that it was bad, mind you. It was high art compared to these cheap basement puppet shows.
But those darn Veggies are too darn lovable. CGI or otherwise, they excelled because they were written as a normal show with normal humor that just so happened to feature biblical teachings. These puppet examples are terrible because they don't even consider fun in the equation. They use puppets to talk down to stupid little kids.
Another thing that makes
VeggieTales stand out from other Christian kids' series I've seen - It's not super-preachy.
VeggieTales teaches values and life-lessons - Ones that
every parent teaches their kids, like standing up for what you believe in, helping those in need, being thankful for what you have, listening to your parents, etc. - and then they relate it to the Christian faith. And when they do teach something religion-specific (like the meaning of Easter, or obeying God) it's still done with a fun story that children will understand and enjoy.
Other Christian shows don't do this. They spend all their time
saying how great Jesus is and telling you to pray and read the Bible, but they don't realistically relate any Christian
values to kids. Religion, after all, is made up of two things - faith and values.
But when you are competing with this...
... it's pretty easy to stand out.
By the way, everyone, this
Puppet Parade garbage was made in
2008! Shocking, isn't it?!