Since you said it's out of the box, you wouldn't be looking at too much for the puppet. If you were to try and sell it on ebay, I would say if you got 40 to 50 dollars you should consider yourself lucky. I've looked on ebay for one in it's original box and I did indeed find one. I kept bidding and bidding, but sadly I was outbidded. If my memory serves me right, I think it went for 150 bucks or so.
So yeah since yours is out of the box, I'm sorry to say, it's not worth much,
.