1. Welcome to the Muppet Central Forum!
    You are viewing our forum as a guest. Join our free community to post topics and start private conversations. Please contact us if you need help with registration or your account login.

  2. "Muppet Guys Talking" Debuts On-line
    Watch the inspiring documentary "Muppet Guys Talking", read fan reactions and let us know your thoughts on the Muppet release of the year.

    Dismiss Notice
  3. Sesame Street Season 48
    Sesame Street's 48th season officially began Saturday November 18 on HBO. After you see the new episodes, post here and let us know your thoughts.

    Dismiss Notice

Your Thoughts: Sesame Street on Scrubs

Discussion in 'Sesame Appearances' started by Phillip, Jan 26, 2009.

  1. lowercasegods

    lowercasegods Well-Known Member

    As a huge fan of both the Muppets and Scrubs, I loved this episode! Well, I loved two thirds of this episode--I really can't get into the three new interns, but that's irrelevant--I loved the way Bill Lawrence (the show's creator) wrote this episode, and the dialogue he gave the Muppets.

    I thought The Todd giving Grover a "High four" was hilarious. I LOVED Oscar being in Janitor's trash cart. The "I never close my eyes" bit was brilliant. And Elmo, well, I admit I've been on the fence with the character for years, but man, I think this appearance may have converted me to a fan. Any moment where someone hugs a Muppet is a great moment, but Elmo's dialogue there, "What? She your woman?" is just awesome. Oh, and the bit with the monster where JD tells him he has a hand inside him--comedy gold!

    And I think giving the Muppets four short but very well done moments in the show worked perfectly. If the show was an all out Muppet-thon (which, don't get me wrong, sounds good in principle), it would have totally gone against the grain of the show and risked being a bit "Jumped the shark-ish". But to have them in well placed fantasy sequences, particularly against the backdrop of a serious tragedy of a woman dealing with her husband dying of cancer, that was poignant, and fit the show to a T.

    And how perfect was it to have JD, a guy my age (34) who was among the first generation of Sesame Street fans, fantasize about the Muppets? Oh, only perfect, that's all!

    And lastly, seriously, good lord, has there ever been a more heart tugging rendition of the Sesame Street song than that which they played over the final dramatic moments of the show? Man, I wish I had Elmo in the room with me then. I needed a Muppet hug.

    So anyway, I just had to chime in and say how much I loved this. Bill Lawrence is obviously a Muppet fan, given that the Scrubs cast had a cameo in the Muppets Christmas special back in 2002, and he utilized them perfectly. I say shake loose the long gestating rumors that Jason Segal is working on a Muppet movie and somebody hire Bill Lawrence to write and direct it. Man, that would be awesome.....
  2. Drtooth

    Drtooth Well-Known Member

    I have to say the Muppets were utilized a million times better here than they were in the Scrubs scene in VMX. And here's why...

    The VMX Scrubs cameo was written basically as a generic medical drama segment, with the cast basically appearing as an advertisement. The scene was written without a basic understanding of the show, and it seemed like a forced promo. I'm a fan of Scrubs, but I still think that sequence is totally unnecessary, and you could have put the cast of ER in there and made basically the same jokes.

    Now, with the Sesame Street fantasy sequence, they integrated the characters into the show to bring up a point, and it's great to see J.D.'s cut scenes have something to do with the plot. And in such a bittersweet way too.

    I felt that there really should have been another segment, and it seems like something was obviously cut from the episode, but all and all I think the cameos were well done. Grover's cameo was the best, I think. Anyone else think they used the same Grover from the A's anatomy sketch (did he wear glasses in that one?).
  3. Baby Gonzo

    Baby Gonzo Well-Known Member

    I agree 100% about the Muppets working better here with the Scrubs cast than VMX. I think you hit the nail on the head about why as well.

    I personally didn't feel as though there was anything missing or as though there should have been another segment. What was included was just right as far as getting the message across and it really did seem like a sincere message.

    I know I'm going to sound like a sap in saying this, but this episode reminded me why I stopped watching Scrubs. It's a great show, but I always feel depressed and down after watching it. :o
  4. Katzi428

    Katzi428 Well-Known Member

    I thought it was cute.The part w/:super: was my favorite! Plus I laughed at the "Grover Five!"

    (I wasn't overly crazy about the Elmo parts...then again I'm not an Elmo fan.....please,no bad PMs from you Elmo lovers,OK?)
  5. i thought the episode was funny especially when the sesame gang was in it. Only it could have used more of them instead of little gags.

    "Hey have you had fantasies about muppets all day?"
    "No i'm straight"
    That part was funny
  6. SesameStMuppets

    SesameStMuppets Well-Known Member

    That was a great episode.

    Oscar's eye bit was a cool shout out to Spinney's book.

    Also, did anybody notice when JD asked if Elmo was a seal? That, too, was a funny reference to Kevin playing Wolfgang.

    I'm definetally buying that from iTunes!
  7. redBoobergurl

    redBoobergurl Well-Known Member

    I liked it. I wasn't sure how it was going to fit in, but then when I saw that it was one of J.D.'s fantasies, it made perfect sense to me. My favorite part was with Grover, but the whole thing was great. Nice plug for Sesame over all. And I also loved the recording at the end.
  8. Cecilia5

    Cecilia5 Member

    I thought it was great. I loved Oscar! :grouchy:

    I also love that song! Can't wait to get my hands on it.
  9. CoOKiE

    CoOKiE Well-Known Member

    I too loved the song. I noticed RIGHT away and was like... the tune sounds like SS... then i heard the lyrics.. n knew i was right.

    I actually loved Elmo's "is this your woman?" I was dy'n from that one!

    I missed the Oscar bit... i joined in during the theme. So, i'll have to hunt that down right now.

    EDIT: I watched it on ABC.com. For anyone who wishes to watch or rewatch... head on over there.

    Also... i never cared for Scrubs... n other then the SS cameos... i really didn't enjoy this episode. They mixed humor and drama horribly. And the JD actor... i dont think he does his character well. Either that or his character isnt written well.
  10. tutter_fan

    tutter_fan Well-Known Member

    The Grover bit with him saying "Give me Four!" going into the "Near", and "Far" bit was insanely hilarious! The "Knuckleheads" bit with Oscar was cute, and the "What? She your woman?" with Elmo was quite unexpected! It was a great episode and I'll never forget it!
    "It all makes sense now!" with the orange (or is it brown) AM was also unexpected!
    All in all, I'd give it a 10/10!
  11. Redsonga

    Redsonga Well-Known Member

    I guess you have to be a fan, I've always loved JD, I just wish he would go back to being more light hearted again, it fits him better even if he has grown :sympathy:
    Elmo did'nt creep me out at all I guess I am use to thinking of him as older than he is suppose to be...
    I wish they could have put Big Bird in there somewhere, I mean he pretty much is SST, most of all if we are talking about JDs generation...
    The end song made me cry..I hope I can find a copy of it somwhere:cry:
  12. The Shoe Fairy

    The Shoe Fairy Well-Known Member

    Does anybody have a recorded Video file of this episode, cause I'm outside the US and therefore can't watch the episode online. I would be grateful If somebody put this up on youtube or owned an Mp4/WMV whatever off a recorder.:smirk:
  13. Redsonga

    Redsonga Well-Known Member

    It is already on youtube here:)
  14. The Shoe Fairy

    The Shoe Fairy Well-Known Member

    Awww, Thanks so much:excited:
    I saw it and downloaded it, and I swear it is one of the best scrubs episodes I have ever seen. I love the grover High-Four thing, and the line from Oscar about his eyes, they were brilliant. i wasn't overly impressed with the Elmo cameo, cause it could have been better, but the Hand inside me joke cracked me up.:super:
  15. Redsonga

    Redsonga Well-Known Member

    It's the weirdest thing, I am so use to thinking of muppets as characters I actually didn't 'get' that joke at first :eek:
  16. The Shoe Fairy

    The Shoe Fairy Well-Known Member

    I am with you all the way. I treat The Muppets as I would a real friend, with great sympathy and respect. Half the time I never even think of them as characters too, esp. Murray Monster, with whom Joey Mazzarino does such a great job.
  17. Redsonga

    Redsonga Well-Known Member

    I know they are all so alive it is like they are the actors..or not even acting that much and living among us getting recorded like a youtube show:eek:.
    So when I saw the hand my first gut reaction was 'OMG, get it out! Hand lymphoma!' :confused: *lol*
  18. The Shoe Fairy

    The Shoe Fairy Well-Known Member

  19. Mr Devco

    Mr Devco Well-Known Member

    I never thought anyone could make the theme song to sesame Street Sound so depressing. It was a good episode. Also on an non-sesame street not, I hope Aziz Ansari becomes a regular
  20. MJTaylor

    MJTaylor Well-Known Member

    Say, weren't the cast from Scrubs in Its a Very Muppet Christmas or whatever it was?

Share This Page