Here's my list. I kept it to the top 10 which goes through Spring 2005. This has been shared with Ken over the past couple days, but I thought I'd jump in on the discussion Jamie started as well.
I've been thinking about the top 10 characters I'd like to see in this lineup taking into account how the general public perceives these characters and also what fans might want too. Some are favorite standbys, others are more sought after. You'll notice in my list, it alternates between a slightly rarer character (Beaker, Janice, Pepe, Scooter, Rowlf) and one of the "top five big guns" (Kermit, Piggy, Fozzie, Gonzo, Animal) with one release per quarter.
(1) Beaker (Winter 2002) - He's planned first and a pretty good choice. Is there ANY way you can make his head move down to just his nose??? His mouth could "move in" when the large figure is pressed down. Just add that one feature and everybody will LOVE Beaker. If you work on adding *one* thing extra to each character like Beaker's head movin' down that isn't included with the regular figure, it will go a long way to thrilling fans.
(2) Great Muppet Caper Reporter Kermit (Spring 2003) - The trenchcoat will add a little more fun than just plain Kermit and is a design that will sell extremely well with fans and casual shoppers alike. A lot of detail can be done on Kermit's coat, hat, and textured skin. We all have a variety of large Kermit plastic figures so that's why I went away from his normal "naked" look.
(3) Janice (Summer 2003) - Janice is going to be a huge seller (mega and the action figures). She's one of the top main characters left that has *never* had a doll or action figures made of her. She's also another female character to help balance out the Mega line. Regular Janice with hat would probably be best here instead of Nurse Janice so that she'll have her most recognizable look to her.
(4) Animal (Fall 2003) - Possible normal Animal with drumsticks. Moveable jaw and definitely moveable eyelids would be a nice touch (maybe they would move from a lever on his back).
(5) Pepe (Winter 2003) - He'll appear a year into the line to give some added life. A lot of great texture can be added on this one not possible with the smaller figure. Enough said, ok.
(6) Miss Piggy (Spring 2004) - My first response here was to maybe do a Pigs in Space Piggy large-scale. Pigs in Space is generally regarded as the most memorable sketch on the show. Her outfit would also work well with a large figure because you could add a lot of detail in the design with her space suit, not possible with the action figure. The Miss Piggy in evening gown has been done a lot before, so that's why the Pigs in Space outfit might be the way to go. Ran this idea by Cindy (since she's the Piggy expert around these parts), and at first she was hesitant but she agreed with me after looking at all the other Piggy stuff out there. We've never had a real Pigs in Space doll/figure before (fisher-price did a bad rip-off), so we're in agreement if you can get Henson on board.
(7) Scooter (Summer 2004) - Scooter's a fan favorite and I'm real excited about seeing a large-scale Muppet Show jacket on him. Thick orange yarn or something might be a possibility for his hair.
(8) Gonzo (Fall 2004) - This needs to be the Gonzo in tux with a lot of detail and texture, especially on his face. A small little chicken emblem on the left-hand breast of his jacket pocket might be a nice touch.
(9) Rowlf (Winter 2004) - Jim Henson's first *major* Muppet and one that fans miss seeing the most. Rowlf holding a musicbook or something might help this figure appeal to musicians.
(10) Comedy Fozzie (Spring 2005) - To conclude the line everyone's favorite furry-man Fozzie. The ability for Fozzie to wiggle his ears from a switch in the back might be a nice touch.
Of these, the ones I'm *most excited* about are Janice, Pepe, and Scooter. Definitely hope mega Muppets get made of these three characters. I did *really* want to put Dr. Teeth on the list just because the detail with a large figure would be amazing. So if the line went twelve figures, I'd add Sam for Summer 2005 and Dr. Teeth for Fall 2005 to conclude the line.