1. Welcome to the Muppet Central Forum!
    You are viewing our forum as a guest. Join our free community to post topics and start private conversations. Please contact us if you need help with registration or your account login.

  2. "Muppet Guys Talking" Debuts On-line
    Watch the inspiring documentary "Muppet Guys Talking", read fan reactions and let us know your thoughts on the Muppet release of the year.

    Dismiss Notice
  3. Sesame Street Season 48
    Sesame Street's 48th season officially began Saturday November 18 on HBO. After you see the new episodes, post here and let us know your thoughts.

    Dismiss Notice

Katy Perry song banned from Sesame Street Season 41

Discussion in 'Sesame Street' started by ssetta, Sep 23, 2010.


Should Katy Perry's song been cut from Sesame Street?

  1. Yes

    29 vote(s)
  2. No

    109 vote(s)

  1. audionics

    audionics New Member

    1- Cookie Monster eating "healthy food"
    2- The "questionable relationship" that warranted the cutting of Ernie and Bert

    If the folks at Sesame Street had always been so spineless when it comes to the opinions of a handful of PC-obsessed parents, we would never have known what happened to Mr. Hooper. After all, isn't death too scary for preschool?
    I wish that people would remember the target audience here. These things that raised so many hackles go right over the heads of the kids who watch. :concern:
  2. tiggergirl19

    tiggergirl19 Well-Known Member

    Wasn't Snopp Dogg onSesame Street? If he was, doesn't his image just promote the use of drugs, no matter what? Are parents that scared of letting their kids see what a grown body looks like, and not just the ones that are constantly on Sesame Street? Why won't these parents just let growing children see what different grown bodies look like, if they won't let them see the different bodies? Children need to hear all types of music, so that they can grow intulectually. If you don't let children grow this way, than they won't know much about the different things that are in the world.
  3. Angelios

    Angelios New Member

    Katy Perry was scammed

    I have to say this ... I think Sesame Street needs to open their eyes and get a grip. I had to have somone show me what the problem was ... I have tolaked to many many outraged parents who agree there was nothing wrong with this skit. Their Might be something wrong with the parenting skills of those involved ... Parents are actually teaching their kids what over reaction and ignorance and censorship are by showing them the video on other sites. The whole thing is a disapointment for me ... I thought Sesame Street was about equality ... and liberating and educating people ... perhaps these are words that are too big for them ... I grew up with on Sesame Street ... I bet they would be just as foolish if say there was a lesbian on the show ... Oh WAIT there were many , what about an asian , Oh Hey there are many of those too ... so a woman wearing a yellow dress is too much ... Perhaps we should examine the video collections of these people .... The little mermaid left little to the Imagination ... need I go on ... Katy Perry should be filing a discrimination suit , I think these people have a problem with another big word "Women". Also was it to be asked , any partent would simply explain these are parts of a woman ... and left it at that. By the way , the video is the best I have seen from Sesame street and Judging from the posts .... I am not in the minority opinion.
  4. MJTaylor

    MJTaylor Well-Known Member

    I saw the video on YouTube and I think it is a pity that SW have decided to not use it in the end as I thought it was rather cute. I didn't see anything racy about it at all. Maybe they could shoot it again with Katy wearing a different outfit. Even if they don't, at least we can still watch it on YouTube.
  5. KrazyKritter

    KrazyKritter New Member

    I am not a fan of Elmo at all. He is one of the things that ruined what used to be a good show (the old ones are available on DVD, so you can see for yourself. It is not just that my tastes have improved with age). This segment, however, is actually cute. He doesn't have such a big part in it, I guess.
    I do not follow much modern music, either, so Katy Perry is not exactly a household name for me. But I saw nothing scanty about those clothes at all. Her breasts are hardly developed enough to notice. Dolly Parton she is not. I've seen small children wear less than that--even little girls wearing no bikini tops in public places. When they are that young, it really isn't a big deal. In this clip, KP is fully clothed, and she even says that she is playing "dress-up," implying that these are not her everyday clothes anyway. Kids DO undress in front of one another, but that reality is not even hinted at in this video.
    This is sweet, G-Rated and even Sesame Street worthy, which is rare on the show since the tragic loss of Jim Henson.
  6. ISNorden

    ISNorden Well-Known Member

    I still think a reshoot with a different outfit (or digital reworking, as one member suggested) would be the best solution. The song itself is kid-friendly, as is Kate's behavior towards Elmo...it's just that her outfit doesn't seem right for a playdate. She and Kevin Clash have both joked about wanting another playdate, so I assume she'd be willing to reshoot if Sesame Workshop had the time and money.
  7. muppet maniac

    muppet maniac Well-Known Member

    Makes me wonder if they've ever heard Roosevelt Franklin's song "Just Because". Whatever happened to the good ol' days of Sesame Street when they taught things like that? :p

    But back on topic...(man, I never thought I'd keep replying to this thread, but oddly enough that's what I'm doing).

    To the people who've said Katy's dress was "too revealing", "skimpy", or whatever, let me ask you this: why do you suppose you think that?

    Because that's the way you, adults, think.

    The outfit we're looking at was no different than something you'd see at a ballroom dance or at a wedding. I don't hear anyone complaining about these areas.

    I said before, I've been out and about my whole childhood, been to beaches, swimming pools, I've seen outfits just like Katy's. Did I ever think about or give a carp about what these people wore wherever I was as a youngster? Nope, natta, bupkis. Neither did my parents (now that tells you something).

    Unless there was a real unjustice going on right now...

    Unless you or someone you know is in great danger...

    YOU NEED TO...
  8. Frogpuppeteer

    Frogpuppeteer Well-Known Member

    this is so inappropriate....give that monster some pants!
  9. Bitterpill

    Bitterpill New Member

    The more things change... In the 50s, TV refused to show Elvis Presley from the waist down because his "sexual gyrations" would corrupt the youth of America. 60 years later, Mrs. Russell Brand can't show cleavage on TV because children might find out that women have...wait for it...BOOBS! When did women get boobs? Wh...y wasn't I informed? [sarcasm mode turned off] Shame on the producers of Sesame Street for caving on this. Another generation being taught that their bodies are dirty, vile, disgusting, etc. As Russell Brand himself said, "Today's episode of Sesame Street will not be brought to you by the number 34 & the letter D". Can we all grow up now, please?
  10. mom2adam

    mom2adam New Member

    I think it is ridiculous to pull the video. If that is considered inappropriate, then take a walk on the beach. You think that kids haven't seen worse there? Half the time you are lucky if some women have their *** covered. I mean it is not even the whole "boob" that is uncovered.
    They have a certain picture for Coppertone sunscreen that has a dog pulling on a baby's diaper and the baby's bum is uncovered. So taking Sesame Street's take on it, then that should be pulled form the shelves.
    This from the people who have Bert :( and Ernie :p sleeping in separate houses/rooms, calling Big Bird, Yellow Bird and Cookie Monster:insatiable: now veggie monster and cookies only a sometimes food. Come On!
    They are taking censorship too far these days.......
  11. minor muppetz

    minor muppetz Well-Known Member

    You know, sometimes I wonder if he did that just to avoid being typecast (after all, he had just ended his series at the time).
  12. Frogpuppeteer

    Frogpuppeteer Well-Known Member

    its because "we" but these actors and actress and sports players at suck high pedestals that when they do something "wrong" the parents and rest of the world is shocked and disgusted, and forgets they we all all human and make mistakes...or in Peewees case no mater how you look at it what he does in his private life
  13. Brinatello

    Brinatello Well-Known Member

    This is what it comes down to: Whoever was thinking the dress was perfect was thinking of an older audience, not the preschoolers. They were thinking here is a show that is still being watched by those who had first seen it when aired during the late sixties, seventies and eighties. So, to them, they figured there's nothing wrong with her outfit when the skit was intended for everyone, not just 2-4 year olds.

    Consider what the show put out during those past decades, some of that stuff was not for young children. I was bored to tears during the live-action skits, didn't even know who Paul Simon was as he strummed his guitar! And who can forget the skit where Cookie Monster wanted to eat Guy Smiley? Oh, my gosh! A vore fetish! Cannibalism! That didn't get pulled now, did it? Nope!

    So, getting back to this skit, the design of Katy's outfit was to appeal to the older audience while the rest of it (cartoon scenery and Elmo) is for the younger audience. They attempted to do both and failed after receiving negative reviews, having them scramble next to quickly pull the plug on it.

    Sorry if someone pointed this out before me. :D
  14. minor muppetz

    minor muppetz Well-Known Member

    No, he was in It's a Very Merry Muppet Christmas Movie, and his scene was cut before it was broadcast.
  15. ISNorden

    ISNorden Well-Known Member

    I can understand the producers wanting to appeal to toddlers and adults at the same time; that's pretty hard to do well, even though some of the older Workshop staff had the knack for reaching all ages at the same time. And yes, a lot of the old-school humor would never make it past network censors now. Slapstick violence like the letter W beating the heck out of poor Kermit? "War" as an example word in that same sketch? Jim Henson would've gotten fired if he were alive and trying to produce a skit like that today. :eek: But I grew up watching that W clobber Kermit, without getting emotionally scarred for life.

    I admit that sounds hypocritical, as much as I've complained about Perry's outfit; I apologize for offending some people here. Different adults have different ideas about what kids shouldn't see on TV, but that bit of cleavage is a lot less graphic than what happened to Kermit in Episode 1. (Or how Chris' bathtub scene got handled in today's episode, for that matter!) A reshoot might still be the best compromise now that the old footage is pulled...but in hindsight, I was wrong to jump on the protesters' bandwagon.
  16. Drtooth

    Drtooth Well-Known Member

    Personally, the most disturbing thing on Sesame Street was this Bird Cartoon Even now it just doesn't sit well with me, especially the deep, threatening male voice saying "BIRRRRD" while the eyes swirled. And the part where it lays an egg, with a very evil sounding sting... I'm glad they don't air that anymore. I think I only caught it once. That and the infamous I Beam... those are more troublesome to kids than a part of the female body that they're too young to even want to see that's pretty much 5/8th covered up... and those are the dirty 5/8s.

    A reshoot or graphic enhancement is a good compromise, considering her bi anthem wasn't the reason a thin minority of parents complained until it got pulled (Did you know Katy actually has Christian Evangelical parents who actually support her?). I don't even believe in that, but the sketch was a LOT more fun that that whiny sounding Feist song they're clearly going to reair in its place. Still don't see Feist's appeal.
  17. tiggergirl19

    tiggergirl19 Well-Known Member

    I really like the video. Some people just like to complain. Others don't ever think things can just be innocent.
  18. beaker

    beaker Well-Known Member

    Wait, Katy Perry is married to Russel Brand? Given he's been one of the main stars of Segal/Stoller's movies the last few years...I wonder if that means we'd get a Katy Perry cameo in the new Muppet movie? Oh how ironic that'd be.

    Im with you all the way. I literally can't find any section of the
    video that seems even remote inappropriate or not age appropriate. Shoot, Yo Gabba Gabba is wayyy more out there and bizarre, which I also think is a pretty good kid's show.

    The sexualization of children continues to sicken and shock us all, yet there it is...little girls wearing shirts that have double entendre/suggestive themes, and there mom's think nothing of it. They literally sell that stuff at the mall, and ya see it everywhere.

    And Im with you on the hatred of Elmo. It's sad, as Kevin Clash to me is a master craftsman, especially when you see him work his magic in person as I have. But hot dang, there is not one Sesame Street production, show, special or product/merchandise that doesn't have Elmo on it. I hate his laughter, his voice, his talking in the third person, his passive aggressive ADHD antics. People say they don't like Murray, but I say Murray is a zillion times better than Elmo. And sadly, when a lot of people think Muppets, they picture that red menace.
  19. beaker

    beaker Well-Known Member

    I just thought the Muppets, and my goodness especially Sesame Street, were about teaching peace.


    I mean, geez...Elmo's dad and Rosita's dad go out and kill people for the government...is this official Sesame canon? Poor Rosita's dad even comes back without the use of his legs(like many US soldiers chewed up and spit out by my government)

    Given all the hullabaloo over the Katy Perry video, why is the US so focused on fighting Muslim fundamentalists when America seems to share the Muslims hatred of women and gays?
  20. Frogpuppeteer

    Frogpuppeteer Well-Known Member

    its funny you mention this and i had to chime in.. near me i see more Yo Gabba Gabba Merch at Newbury comics than any other child store

    Mostly stuff surrounding one character mainly the "One Eyed Monster" if thats not a sexual innuendo i dont know what is

Share This Page